Seagate BarraCuda 4TB
Seagate · MPN ST4000DM004
Why this NAS-Safe score? (15/100 — Not recommended for NAS)▾
The NAS-Safe Score rates suitability for 24×7 multi-bay NAS / RAID use on a 0–100 scale. It is additive and fully transparent — every point is attributable to a named factor below. Medium confidence — 1 input unverified, scored with neutral partial credit (never guessed).
- Recording technology0/35
SMR — write-amplification can stall RAID rebuilds
- Vendor NAS endorsement0/15
Not marketed as a NAS-class drive
- Rotational-vibration sensors0/15
No RV sensors — vibration sensitivity in multi-bay chassis
- Rated workload6/15
55 TB/yr — below NAS tier
- MTBF rating5/10
MTBF unknown — partial credit
- Warranty4/10
2-year warranty — short for NAS use
⚠ SMR recording: risky for RAID/NAS rebuilds; prefer CMR for arrays.
Sources
- Seagate CMR/SMR product list — BarraCuda 3.5" row lists 4TB and 8TB under SMR · verified 2026-07-29
Specs
Specs unverified- Capacity
- 4 TB
- Class
- DESKTOP
- Recording
- SMR
- RPM
- 5,400
- Cache
- 256 MB
- Form factor
- 3.5"
- Interface
- SATA 6Gb/s
- Warranty
- 2 years
- Workload
- 55 TB/yr rated
Use-case fit
- backup
Live offers(4 retailers)
Price ratings compare a drive against its own price history and the other listings of that same drive — not against other drives. The $/TB badge is the cross-drive comparison. Neither is a compatibility or reliability recommendation.
- eBayNewSeller risk: lowExcellent pricefor this drive· 88
Why this DealScore? (88/100 — Excellent price for this drive)▾
DealScore rates only whether the price is good right now (0–100), and only for this drive: it blends this listing's own price history with the other live listings of the same model. It is not a comparison against other drives — the $/TB badge does that — and use-case fit (NAS-Safe) and seller risk are scored separately.
Price assessment only — not a compatibility or reliability recommendation.
- Historical price positionn/a×60%
insufficient history (<3 points)
- Market price position88/100×40%
4 comparable listings
$39.49/TB — limited price history; beats 88% of comparable listings on $/TB.
—$157.97$39.49/TB - eBayNewSeller risk: lowExpensivefor this drive· 31
Why this DealScore? (31/100 — Expensive for this drive)▾
DealScore rates only whether the price is good right now (0–100), and only for this drive: it blends this listing's own price history with the other live listings of the same model. It is not a comparison against other drives — the $/TB badge does that — and use-case fit (NAS-Safe) and seller risk are scored separately.
Price assessment only — not a compatibility or reliability recommendation.
- Historical price position10/100×60%
5 price points
- Market price position63/100×40%
4 comparable listings
$40.00/TB — pricier than 90% of its own price history; beats 63% of comparable listings on $/TB.
↑ $10.00 (+6.7%)$159.99$40.00/TB - eBayNewSeller risk: lowExpensivefor this drive· 20
Why this DealScore? (20/100 — Expensive for this drive)▾
DealScore rates only whether the price is good right now (0–100), and only for this drive: it blends this listing's own price history with the other live listings of the same model. It is not a comparison against other drives — the $/TB badge does that — and use-case fit (NAS-Safe) and seller risk are scored separately.
Price assessment only — not a compatibility or reliability recommendation.
- Historical price position8/100×60%
6 price points
- Market price position38/100×40%
4 comparable listings
$40.87/TB — pricier than 92% of its own price history; beats 38% of comparable listings on $/TB.
↑ $10.50 (+6.9%)$163.49$40.87/TB - B&HnewExpensivefor this drive· 11
Why this DealScore? (11/100 — Expensive for this drive)▾
DealScore rates only whether the price is good right now (0–100), and only for this drive: it blends this listing's own price history with the other live listings of the same model. It is not a comparison against other drives — the $/TB badge does that — and use-case fit (NAS-Safe) and seller risk are scored separately.
Price assessment only — not a compatibility or reliability recommendation.
- Historical price position10/100×60%
10 price points
- Market price position13/100×40%
4 comparable listings
$42.25/TB — pricier than 90% of its own price history; beats 13% of comparable listings on $/TB.
↑ $10.00 (+6.3%)$169.00$42.25/TB
Prices snapshotted daily. See our scoring methodology.